Review: Cydia 2.0 vs Installer 4.0

Posted by Nic Elder on: July 24th, 2008, 3.48 pm

What is Cydia?

If you’ve just used one of the new Pwnage options and now have a shiny new jailbroken iPhone running the 2.0 software, then you might be asking yourself, “What is Cydia?”

You might also be asking yourself, “Where is Installer?,” but rest assured it is coming soon. Until then, let’s explain Cydia.

Cydia was created by Jay Freeman (saurik), as an alternative to Installer. It took what Installer started and improved on it. It’s open source and gives developers much more flexibility when publishing their apps.

But why is Cydia on your SpringBoard and not Installer?

Well the 2.0 software introduces many changes to the developer’s toolchain, which means that applications written for 1.1.4 and below will not run on 2.0 firmware without being updated and recompiled. At the time PwnageTool was released, Installer itself had not been ported to the 2.0 software, and therefore cannot run on it yet.

Until the developers of Installer (RiP Dev) finish updating the application, it will not run on the new 2.0 iPhone/iPod Touch software. In the meantime, Cydia is your sole method of package installation.

Now you’re probably saying, “But Installer had so many more apps than Cydia.”

The reason there are so few apps (specifically games and customization utilities) in Cydia, is the same reason there is no Installer on the iPhone yet.

These apps haven’t been updated by the individual developers. Cydia will only display apps that can run on your iPhone, and as the individual developers update their apps, they will appear in Cydia as well, so check back frequently.

Apps are being updated on a daily, if not hourly, basis. My favorite app, the NES emulator, is already available. I mean, be honest, the only reason we jailbreak in the first place is to play Super Mario Bros., right?

Installer 4.0 appears to address many of the shortcomings of the original Installer.app, the very issues that sparked saurik to develop Cydia.

Some things the new Installer is said to include, according to RiP Dev, are ‘dependencies’. This means if an app requires another app or package to be installed, it will automatically download the other packages and install them (as long as they are available).

Installer 4.0 will also be fully multi-threaded, so now you can refresh sources, browse packages, and install packages all at the same time; no more waiting for the “refreshing sources” message at the bottom of the screen to go away (sometimes 10 or 15 minutes later).

But the largest improvement that Installer 4.0 will boast is using sqlite database. Previously it used PLIST files which had to be fully downloaded every time sources were refreshed. Some of these files were rather large (700kb to 1mb for larger sources), putting a strain on the webservers hosting the files. Now we just get information added or removed since our last refresh. This will also make searching and startup muchimproved.

Whether your preference is the new Installer 4.0 or Cydia, rest assured they will both play nicely together. Some developers will only package their apps in an Installer repository, and some will only put theirs in Cydia, and of course some will publish to both. No matter what the developer’s preference you will be able to run Cydia, Installer, and AppStore all on your iPhone with no problems.

105 Comments

  1. Do you think that when Installer 4.0 is available, that it will be available for download through Cydia 2.0? I don’t know whether I should wait for Installer and a new Winpwn that installs it or whether I should pwn now, and then download Installer through Cydia (if that’s possible).

  2. Hi,4
    Where can i found wich app are there in Cydis?
    Thanks.

  3. @max: I’m not sure whether the RIP Dev will choose to release installer using a cydia source, it would certainly work to their advantage. Either way if you pwn your phone now, then when installer is released you would only need to create a new custom firmware in winpwn with installer, and restore using itunes (make sure you let a backup complete first).

    @Quiqueal: I haven’t found a good list of apps that have been ported to 2.0 yet, but the absolute best place to look is check the ‘Changes’ section within cydia daily. It contains all newly available apps. Currently other than Macman and NES, most of the apps are command line utilites, and there are some wallpaper / dialer packs there.

  4. @Nic: Thanks for your help. I guess I’ll wait until the next firmware update and then pwn after that. Maybe Installer will be available by then and be a part of Winpwn.

  5. Or, you could wait until 2.1, or you could wait until 2.2, or you could wait until 6 months from now. There will ALWAYS be something new and updated. Waiting for stability is okay, but waiting for the next new thing will always leave you waiting. Honestly, if you have a full back-up, it’s not really that hard to do the re-pwn.

  6. ok

  7. Do you know when the installer 4.0 is coming out?

  8. how do you install cydia on a 3g iphone using windows vista
    is it possible you can show me step by step… would it harm my iphone and would i be able to use everything like a normal iphone??????? thank you

  9. @ rubmjr Check this site out i follow the tutorial and it was easy im running Win Xp.

    Winpwn will install Cydia for you, make sure you get the newest the got links for you need there WinPwn 2.0.0.3.

  10. Installer and Cydia are just apps. The only thing that jailbreaking does is allow your apps to run without having to be signature checked by the kernel. It doesn’t matter which one you have installed first, you will be able to install the other without re-jailbreaking.

    @Nic: “it would certainly work to their advantage” – they are not competitors. Installer had some issues, Cydia improved on those. As a developer, just because some other software came out that works better, doesn’t mean that you stop improving yours. In fact, in most cases, it drives you to improve on the improved.

  11. @nate: I never said they were competitors, though I think that by definition they are. However I mean from a distribution standpoint creating a cydia package is the easiest, quickest way to get the Installer app into users hands.

  12. @nate: If someone is not familiar w/ the process of SSH/SFTP and manually installing applications then they may have to make a new custom firmware including Installer when it comes out. This is what I meant by “it would certainly work to their advantage”. It would allow novice users to get the app easily.

  13. Well Well nice i have an jailbreak ipod touch firmware 1.1.2 and i love everythin i have sumpref, customize and my games… Cydia i never tryed out cydia but trust me i am going to wait untill Installer 2.0/2.1 comes out i cant wait until it comes out installer is way better…

  14. I jailbroke my iphone 3g the day i could jailbreak it. After having the itouch jailbroken it was hard to use the iphone for two weeks un-jailbroken. But yay for winpwn. Way easier then when i first got my itouch and had to downgrade from 1.1.3 to 1.1.1 and work my way up each firmware. Thank God those days are gone. Loading the custom ipsw is such a time saver. First time a jailbroke an itouch it took me a good 3 to 4 hours to figure it out. with winpwn it took me less than 10 minutes. And i redid it again so i could create my own boot and recovery with photoshop.

  15. before on previous 1.1.X versions installer allowed you to install cydia and cydia allowed you to install installer. I would not worry about Cydia not allowing you to install Instaler

  16. @Jonathan: Just for curiosity’s sake, as well as to help the developer of Cydia improve their product, what about Installer makes it better for you?

  17. Is there any app available to copy/browse files on my iPhone ? I would like to cope docs to my iPhone for referance purposes etc.

  18. i read that it should be available thru the cydia installer and thru pwnage or winpwn….either way u will end up wid installer….

  19. is there gonna be a way to send songs from your iPod thru email?

  20. Cydia is improving….still crashes sometimes… (but improving day by day…recently gave option to add resources)… Installer simply rocks…in looks and features

  21. Is the Installer is out yet to be downloaded through the Cydia app? update on this….

  22. Is it possible to have both Cydia and installer 4.0 on your screen or springbord and both to operate at the same time?
    this is because i had installer on mine and later when my iphone was upgraded i saw cydia and i`m somtimes confused as where to find most of the programms i had using installer.
    and how do i get NES and GBA to play games on my iphone?

  23. Installer 4 has no sources or programms… is it normal? Or is something wrong with my installer?

  24. Can you run installer without cydia?

  25. @albert: yes you can!
    @Peete: here’s some sources for Installer 4.0 – http://www.appleiphoneapps.com/2008/08/installer-40-beta-sources/
    @kams: of course, but Installer currently has very few sources available and is in a rough beta version.

  26. Hey! I would like to ask. I have Cydia on my 2G 2.0 iPhone, but it seems like there is no IM app available through that (please correct me if Im mistaken), so is it possible (and how) to get Installer as well? Wont there be problem for those 2 to wok together?
    Thank you

  27. @feraverto: I don’t think there are any IM apps available on Cydia or Installer for 2.0. There are multiple options for IM apps now available in the AppStore so most of the IM developers moved there.

    See the reviews for Mobile Chat and Palringo here:
    http://www.appleiphoneapps.com/?s=messenger

  28. I would like to know if there is and application for syncing the Rainlendar Calendar with iPhone.

  29. I’m new to alot of this iPhone stuff, I had a quick question. First of all i have the new iphone 3g, and question was. “Where do I go to jailbreak my iPhone 3g(what website do I go to?). And also where do I go to get the installer 4.0? And I want cydia on my phone as well. I know it’s alot but can somebody give like a step-by-step to do all this. Thank u

  30. @bug: Jailbreaking will install both cydia and installer on the phone. We have a few articles and tutorials about jailbreaking on our site..

  31. Where can I install Cydia from? Is it for Jailbreak phones only?

  32. @Mintsuze: yes, cydia is installed automatically when jailbreaking the phone.

  33. no comment

  34. i’m a newbie
    where/How can i download Cydia? download it by the phone or PC?

  35. how to install cydia?? and where we can download cydia??

  36. It is installed automatically when you jailbreak it. I have the 3G 16BG one fully updated to 2.2 and i just used Quickpwn and it has everything on it for me. It’s very user friendly!

  37. As a Novice, I wanted my iPhone V 2.2 Jailbroken. Cydia is awesome! It was Easy to setup. Just Youtube Cydia and there are all kinda 12 yr old kids showing you how to do this Step by Step!
    I will NEVER be able to Live without Cydia !! Now, I’m looking for Mods for my Mac Book Pro and I also can’t find where How to have the big Farris wheel/ (Price is right wheel)! I saw a guy at the airport with this Theme and it was MINDBLOWING!!! Help?

  38. I wish to holy **** that saurik would stop heaving those butt-hideous HUGE ads all over his application – it’s really getting annoying now. I will NEVER click through on any of that stuff, he won’t make a penny from me that way – I’d happily pay a license fee to get rid of all that crap every time I launch anything in Cydia.

  39. cydia

  40. where do I go to download Cydia.

  41. Where do i download cydia.

  42. i think cydia is better than installer.

  43. so can i have both Cydia and the installer for iphone 3G on my new iphone?
    i already have Cydia but where can i find the installer for the 3G?

  44. Not even close, cydia is much much much better than installer. There are a whole lot of more apps available for download in cydia. Fraknly, I think putting installer on your iphone or ipod touch is a waste of time. Cydia is definately the way to go

  45. i got my iphone 2g unlocked and i have both CYDIA and INSTALLER, and i want application but am afraid of locking up my iphone, can someone explain how i can get application free? am scared to click on this cydia thing.

  46. My iphone 3g is jailbroken and I have cydia and installer however when I download apps from either they don’t show up as an icon or in the winterboard (themes) but they do show up as installed on the phone but for some reason I can’t use them even after I restarted my phone…Is there something i’m not doing or something else I need to install please help.

    • I have just run into the same problem you did back in January. How did you solve your problem?

  47. Hey Ron,

    I was reading around I think you might have to change your settings in Cydia to “User” and make sure your are not logged in as a hacker or Developer… Because if you are you are downloading apps which are meant for developing the brillant apps out there… hope that helps!

  48. hi there… is there a java platform for the iphone yet…. i have just jailbroken my iphone this week and have not been able to find a java platform… i haved many games and chat facilities that run on java and cant use them because of the iphone not running java. i do know that the developers of the software for the chat programs are looking at creating applications for iphone but they are not even close to being ready for release. please could you get back to me at tritonjl@gmail.com also i live in south africa and my carrier does not have the OTA settings for iphone… where can i find these

    looking forward to some1s help
    best regards

  49. I have a 16 gb jailbreak 2G Iphone which have the Cydia 2.0 Installer. I have been given a 16gb 3G Iphone that need not be jailbroken. I find your Cydia 2.0 Installer fantastic can download Cydia 2.0 Installer and used in 3G Iphone. Please advise

  50. How can i get Cydia and Installer?

  51. How do i get games from the Apps store and 3rd party stuff for free???

    • iMpatch via cydia

  52. its great. Can’t wait to install it

  53. I had an unlocked/jailbroken iphone once before with cydia. it was givin to me like that and i loved it. however it was on the verge of failing and did. I got another one for christmas and had the same friend that gave me my last one jailbrake my new one for me. however this time cydia isn’t on in. I tried the entering address in the source part of Installer but it says it’s invalid. I have no idea what firmware i have. So what do i do now to get Cydia?

  54. ff

  55. jedx

  56. oye we quiero saver como descargar el cydia es q tengo el ipod touch pero lo tengo vasio dime como lo descargo xfa va

    • porfa dime como descargar videorecorde para iphone 3g porfa

  57. when will the jailbreak come out for the ipod touch 2g?

    • now,its called quickfreedom and its untethereed

      • It is only for windows……. anyone know of a mac friendly way to jailbreak 2g itouch??

  58. Is it true that when you put cydia on your ipod touch that it will void the warranty?

    • it won’t void the warranty, but, as far as i know, its an illegal thing to do. so if something happens with your iPhone and someone from the apple store tells you that it was because of the jailbreak there’s nothing they can do.

      once again, i think its illegal…

  59. ddcvvbb

  60. haveing problems with Installer, wont start after I touch a icon, why? Plz help me!

  61. how can i get cydia and where can i get it?

  62. How can I get cydia?

  63. get jailbreak

  64. hey guys i have 1.1.4 iPhone and I’m wondering is it posible to install cydia on my phone and if it is how?

  65. How do i add new source link to my cydia and installer for jailbroken 2G phone.. can any one help me out with these….plz

    • i want to put or copy cydia in my mobile because i dont use it because there is not any thing so this program will help me i am watting for your answer thanks

  66. hands down cydia the best

  67. How can I download cydia for my iPhone 3G?

  68. I just bought a jailbroken 8G iPhone and everything was looking great. I was checking out all of the icons when I touched Cydia to see what it was and EVERYTHING on the phone disappeared! One icon remains which is UTube and nothing else. Seriously, where did it go and how do I get everything back?!

    • dont panic!

      you have to put your phone on DFU mode and restore thru iTunes!

      do you know how to do that?
      of not, let me know!

      good luck!

    • Hey, did you go to Baylor?

  69. I jailbroke my phone the other day and used the following instruction:

    http://www.iclarified.com/entry/index.php?enid=1881

    By all accounts you can recover using this method if your phone goes bad too….

  70. How I can download Cydia in my Iphone 3G?

    • How can I get Cydia for my Iphone 3G

  71. quiero bajar cydia para mi iphone

    • no tengo un webside

      • no tengo web que puedo hacer

    • quiero instalar en mi iphone

    • quiero instalar en mi

  72. it’s a lovely software

  73. When i click on the Cydia Icon on the iphone a box appears saying ‘who are you? not all packages available via cydia are designed to be used by all users. Please categorize yourself so that Cydia can applu helpful filters’

    It then lets me choose from 3 options, – user (graphic only), Hacker or developer. it doesnt matter which one i choose it just takes me back to the main page of icons and i cant get into cydia.

    Does anyone know how to fix this…?

    • hi i have the problime you have if you fix this problim plz rply me
      thanks alot

  74. i have cydia i downloaded it at may 6 2009
    and i can’t enter sources when i go to manage it show pacages automaticly wats the problem?

  75. i have cydia i downloaded it at may 6 2009
    and i can’t enter sources when i go to manage it show pacages automaticly wats the problem? i appreaciate any help

  76. hey guys can someone please help with jail breaking my ipod touch version 2.2.2 just email me in my name thanks!

  77. how do you get cydia on your ipod touch

    • you have to do the jailbreak!

  78. how do i get cydia on my ipod touch

  79. hi people how can i instal cydia on my iphone
    ich hab already this version 3.0.
    It’s posibil to install now the cydia or not ?
    pls help me people

    • it is possible to download Cydia on your iPhone 3G.

      iclarified is a good website!

  80. how do i even install it on my ipod i cant find it in the app store or itunes where can i go to get installer/cydia. im so frustrated right now!!:(

  81. i iinstall cydia and now is coming an error telling me to springboard has been crash, and i have to reboot when i reboot i getting freeze my slide to unlock is not workingg and is keeping rebooting all the the time. i have to wait till battery is over and then it will work when i start charging it but in safe mode.

  82. Download cydia

  83. How to install cydia

  84. When trying to install Cydia (blackrain) installation always crashes (timeouts and so on) is there a way to download Cydia-Application with PC?
    Downloadlink?

  85. Where do I find cydia I’m in Australia & can’t find where to get it from please help.

  86. hi I have Iphone 3g 16 GB and installed cydia but i want also the installer app , can any 1 help me and show me the way 2 have them both

  87. I lik this

  88. I lik this wby

Leave a Response