Comparison: Weather App Comparison

Posted by Brian Fischer on: March 12th, 2009, 5.00 am

The weather apps available for your iphone vary as much as… um… the weather? I guess? Some have a lot of features and will come in handy. Others, not so much. I’m comparing six apps, AccuWeather, Weatherbug, Weather Channel, WeatherEye, WeatherNow and Fizz Weather… and for kicks I’m including the Weather app that comes pre-installed on your phone. You know the one… you can’t get rid of it. (Yeah, that one.) Enjoy. Or don’t. See if I care.

Weather

weather Comparison: Weather App Comparison

 

 

Weather

 

Overview

This is about as stripped down weather app as you can possibly get. Six day forecast and the current temperature, via Yahoo weather. It’s pre-installed and you can’t delete it from your phone. So learn to deal with it, man.

weather1 Comparison: Weather App Comparison weather2 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

Bottom Line

Since it comes included with your phone, you’ll have this app no matter what. Even if you hate it, you can’t get rid of it. It’s just there. (This is assuming that you’re not all smart and rebellious and jailbreak your phone.) It lacks a lot of the fun, detailed features that the other apps… uh… feature. Yes. If you’re looking for an hourly breakdown- you better look elsewhere, cause it ain’t here, my friend.

 

Verdict: Does It Really Matter? You’re Stuck With It.

 

AccuWeather.com

accu Comparison: Weather App Comparison

 

 

AccuWeather.com v1.02 | Published by AccuWeather, Inc. | Via App Store | FREE | Released: 12-12-08

 

Overview

AccuWeather doesn’t mess around with the features. Current conditions, next five hour breakdown, five day forecast, air quality and UV index levels, radar, maps alerts and video. It’s like an overload after having only used the boring weather app that’s pre-installed. It’s all very exciting. I mean… there’s videos! You can watch weather videos! (I’d find out later that there are a few apps that include video).

accu1 Comparison: Weather App Comparison accu2 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

accu3 Comparison: Weather App Comparison accu5 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

accu6 Comparison: Weather App Comparison accu8 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

Bottom Line

This is a swell little weather app. It has a lot of good features and they’re easy to understand. I’m not a fan of the ad banner at the top, but it’s not a deal breaker. The videos are a nice touch and I like the risk page that lists the potential severe weather over the next 8 hours. (Unfortunately, they’re always low here in LA. Aww.) Considering that this is a free app, you could do a lot worse… (see the following review for an example of “worse.”)

 

Verdict: The Sun Is Shining On This App

 

WeatherBug

weatherbug Comparison: Weather App Comparison

 

 

WeatherBug v1.1.1 | Published by WeatherBug | Via App Store | FREE | Released: 07-06-08

 

Overview

Okay, this app features a three day forecast, (including today), radar/satellite maps, weather cameras, and a video forecast. The forecast is pretty detailed. It includes the wind speed, wind chill, humidity and dew point. Oh yeah, it also features the temperature. Which is good, because 9 times out of 10, you’re probably most interested in the temperature. And it’s got it!

weatherbug1 Comparison: Weather App Comparison weatherbug2 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

weatherbug3 Comparison: Weather App Comparison weatherbug4 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

Bottom Line

This app is merely okay. It lacks an extended forecast, and an hourly breakdown that the others feature. And, from a merely aesthetic standpoint, it’s just not that exciting. It’s kind of bland. And I know how much excitement counts when you’re checking the weather.

 

Verdict: Cloudy, With A Chance Of Rain

 

The Weather Channel

twc Comparison: Weather App Comparison

 

 

The Weather Channel v1.0.1 | Published by The Weather Channel Interactive, Inc. | Via App Store | FREE | Released: 11-04-08

 

Overview

This is an app made by The Weather Channel… let me repeat that… an app made by The Weather Channel. They’re the weather experts. I mean, they have their own channel on cable, (which they use to perpetuate the global warming hoax.) So this app should be pretty good right? It features current weather conditions, hourly breakdowns, 36 hour breakdown, 10 day forecast, video, severe weather alerts and an interactive map of the area where you can view the radar, cloud level, temperature and rainfall. Phew! And it’s all free!

twc1 Comparison: Weather App Comparison twc3 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

twc4 Comparison: Weather App Comparison twc5 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

twc6 Comparison: Weather App Comparison twc7 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

Bottom Line

It’s got everything you could possibly need, minus snow reports, and it’s free. Since it’s free, you can download it and try it for yourself it you don’t want to take my word for it. And if you don’t want to take my word for it, then you have trust issues, because I’m about as honest a person as they come. (Although, I know there’s a difference between being honest and stating an opinion… I mean this is purely subjective. You might hate this app for some reason. That doesn’t mean that you’re right or wrong, since it’s all just an opinion we’re talking about here.)

 

Verdict: The Sun Is Shining On This App

 

WeatherEye

weathereye Comparison: Weather App Comparison

 

 

WeatherEye v2.0.10 | Published by Pelmorex Media Inc. | Via App Store | FREE | Released: 10-21-08

 

Overview

This app features a five day forecast and an evening/next day forecast. Um… it also features current conditions. It has a place where the sunrise and sunset would be, but it says N/A in those places. Which is lame, because Los Angeles is a big city. That’s about it as far as features go.

weathereye1 Comparison: Weather App Comparison weathereye2 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

weathereye3 Comparison: Weather App Comparison weathereye4 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

Bottom Line

Okay, this is dumb. Out of all of the apps, this is the only one that couldn’t locate my current position. I couldn’t locate Burbank. Burbank. A suburb of Los Angeles. A major city in the valley… It can’t find Burbank?! I’m sorry, but what? Burbank is a real city! Why can’t you locate it?!

Besides that, it’s missing a lot of features that the others had… like an hourly breakdown of conditions, rader, maps, etc. And I found that on the extended forecasts, most of the details came up as N/A. And that pretty much defeats the purpose of having an extended forecast.

 

Verdict: Rainy Days & Mondays (And This App) Always Get Me Down

 

WeatherNow

weathernow Comparison: Weather App Comparison

 

 

WeatherNow v3.2 | Published by AlbeBaubles | Via App Store | $2.99 | Released: 01-23-09

 

Overview

WeatherNow offers a five day forecast featuring the highs and lows for those days and the current temperature. It includes sunrise and set too. The time and date are stamped right there… much larger than the actual temperature for some reason. If you turn your phone sideways, you get the temperature displayed over a pretty picture. That’s all the features though. And yes, they do charge you for this app…

weathernow1 Comparison: Weather App Comparison weathernow2 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

weathernow3 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

Bottom Line

Wow. This one is pretty worthless. It’s neat(?) that it has the time and date and location on it… but… the time is an hour ahead of what we in Burbank like to call “real” time. (After the daylight savings time, it was 8 hours off, but as of right now, the clock is accurate.) It sucks that you can’t store locations- so you’re forced to enter your zip code or shake the phone for the current location. Lame! The forecasts aren’t detailed and there are no maps or radar… it’s very disappointing and not worth the price they’re charging. Even if it were free, I wouldn’t recommend it. Sorry.

 

Verdict: Rainy Days & Mondays (And This App) Always Get Me Down

 

Fizz Weather

fizz Comparison: Weather App Comparison

 

 

Fizz Weather v1.02 | Published by Fizz Software Ltd. | Via App Store | $5.99 | Released: 02-04-09

 

Overview

Fizz Weather has a two day and five day forecast for over 58,000 cities around the world. It features wind speed, sunset and sunrise times, radar maps and loops and airport information. If you rotate your phone you can get forecast charts for temperature, precipitation, rainfall, humidity and wind. And what kind of a weather app would be complete without weather alerts? Seriously, would it be complete without that? I don’t think so.

fizz1 Comparison: Weather App Comparison fizz2 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

fizz3 Comparison: Weather App Comparison fizz4 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

fizz5 Comparison: Weather App Comparison fizz6 Comparison: Weather App Comparison

Bottom Line

This app is good. It looks nice and more importantly, it’s accurate. Lots of detailed weather info. The problem is, you can get all of that info for free from the other apps, like The Weather Channel one. I’m not sure how they can justify charging that much money for this app. But it’s their prerogative, so… whatever. If it were cheaper, or free, this would probably be my most favoritest…. actually, my second most favoritest, because it doesn’t include a 10 day forecast. And when it comes to weather, I need to know 10 days in advance. Because of the price, I’m forced to lower my opinion…

 

Verdict: Cloudy, With A Chance Of Rain

 

The Final Word

 

 

Since I know by now you’re probably pretty freakin’ tired reading about the weather, because the weather is soooo boring… so I’ll make this short and sweet. Both AccuWeather and The Weather Channel apps are well worth the cost… which is zero, because they’re free. Fizz Weather would be great- if it weren’t six dollars. I’m sorry, but there are some things in life you just don’t pay for: The weather forecast is one of those things.

(And if you don’t agree, so what? It’s a free app!)

The Winner

twc Comparison: Weather App Comparison
The Weather Channel | FREE | Must Have

13 Comments

  1. Were you trying to inflate the readership of this review with the global warming jab? Without agreeing or not, I found that little jab annoying. Otherwise a good review, personally Accuweather is still my favorite mostly because of the extra eye-candy.

    • You clearly have no idea what you are saying. We are coming out of the Little Ice Age, it’s going to warm, so get used to it! If this was 600 years ago, you’d be complaining about how cold it was getting! This is why the Vikings had to slowly move back to Europe… The world goes in cycles, and you’re left by the wayside. Take one for the team you liberal hippy and choke on the icecube of reality.

  2. I personally use Fizz Weather. I like it a lot :)

    WeatherEye is targeted towards Canadian weather, I’m pretty sure.

  3. You left off one of the best weather apps. Weather Underground’s web app does a great job. I use it more than any of the others. The URL is wund.com

  4. For the jailbreakers, you might want to mention WeatherIcon. It modifies the standard iPhone weather app so that the actual temperature and conditions are displayed on the Weather icon instead of the constant 73 degrees and sunny. It’s extremely convenient. If the Calendar icon can display the real date, why can’t the Weather icon display the real weather and temperature?

  5. Motionmind,

    That was a joke about the global warming, referencing James M. Inhofe, a senator from Oklahoma, (a state known for being brilliant), who called global warming a hoax and that the Weather Channel created it to boost their ratings.

    Oddly enough, the founder of the Weather Channel, John Coleman, also called global warming a scam…

    For the record, I believe in global warming. We should all ride bikes.

  6. @Brent:

    wund.com? are you serious? first of all, it’s merely a web *site* (not a web *app*). it’s not exactly attractive, and it’s not even formatted for the iphone! so, how you can even begin to equate it with the apps in this review is puzzling.

  7. I have both Fizz Weather and MyWeather on my iPhone, I am very surprised you guys didn’t toss in a review for MyWeather.

    But, I use Fizz Weather mostly. I got MyWeather because it went on sale and figured “Why not!”.

  8. What about a sunrise sunset app? There’s a new one that just came up in the app store. It’s FREE and is a great weather utility to have. When you need it it’s priceless! http://itunes.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewSoftware?id=309409507&mt=8

  9. Have you checked out Nav Clock, an IPhone Weather App created by Split Rail, Inc?

    I think this is an awesome app. It gives time, location, weather, barometric pressure trending with cool background photos of current sky conditions. Just about anything you could want or need. The developer seems to be easy to contact and open to user suggestions. The notes say he is working on Sunset/Sunrise for a future version. It works on iPod Touch too.

  10. You forgot Hot Weather :D

  11. It’s not an app, but I really love weather.gov.

    It’s a government site, so if you are a US taxpayer, you are already paying for it.

    I have three safari weather bookmarks: The 48 hour weather graph for my hometown, the Northeast Loop: http://radar.weather.gov/Conus/northeast_loop.php, and the 7 day forecast for my hometown.

    I especially like the 48 hr weather graph with predicted temperatures and probabilities of precipitation.

  12. “Take one for the team you liberal hippy and choke on the icecube of reality.”

    whenever I see comments like this one, I feel that we are choking on the ice cube of stupidity.

    But anyway thanks for the good overview of weather apps.

Leave a Response